AD-FREE EPISODES
TSP #48 – Michael Colucci’s Volatile Marriage in the Days Before His Wife’s Death + A Member of Colucci Family Speaks Out
The Colucci Case
TSP #47 – A Good Day for Stopping a Judicial Election – Bowen Turner’s Latest Ride to Jail + Texts Expose Volatility of Michael and Sara Lynn Colucci’s Marriage
What Happened to Sarah Lynn Colucci
TSP #46 – The Chaotic Life of Michael Colucci + Bowen Turner’s Entitlement on Full Display in Police Video
What Happened to Sarah Lynn Colucci
TSP #45 – Alex Murdaugh Sentenced AGAIN, PMPED and PSB’s “Dirty Hands” Plus Where in the World is Michael Colucci?
On today's True Sunlight Podcast, Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell update you on what went down at Alex Murdaugh’s federal sentencing hearing this week, where he was sentenced to 40 years. What does this new sentence mean? And why does Alex have to pay back...
TSP #44 – Feds Fight For PMPED & Palmetto State Bank. Did Cory Provide Evidence? + Becky Hill’s Absurd Presser
On today's True Sunlight Podcast, Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell break down what happened at Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill’s pathetic last attempt at staying in the post-Alex Murdaugh spotlight and why there might be more to the story about Becky’s...
TSP #43 – What Happened to Sara Lynn Colucci? Part One: The Story the Jury SHOULD Have Been Told + Victims Matter Rally
On today's True Sunlight Podcast, Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell begin their dive down the complex rabbit hole that is the Sara Lynn Moore-Colucci case. Sara Lynn was killed on the evening of May 20, 2015, outside of Charleston, South Carolina, at a jewelry...
TSP #42 – Bowen Turner Is Arrested Again + the 911 Call from the Night of Sara Lynn Colucci’s Death
On today's True Sunlight Podcast, Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell talk to South Carolina Victims Assistance Network attorney Sarah Ford and Karl Stoller, a father who continues to seek justice for his daughter’s sexual assault, about the latest arrest of Bowen...
TSP #41 – Who Killed Stephen Smith? Part Eleven… The Voice We Have Not Heard Yet + The Colucci Case
On today's True Sunlight Podcast, Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell continue their investigation into the photos and screenshots found on Stephen Smith’s phone, learning more about what the Hampton, S.C., teen’s life was like leading up to his mysterious death in...
TSP #40 – Who Killed Stephen Smith? Part Ten… Newly Recovered Photos Tell Us About Who He Was And Could Have Been
True Sunlight Podcast co-hosts True Sunlight Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell continue to unpack the evidence in the Stephen Smith case file. On today’s episode they take a look at the thousands of photos downloaded from Stephen’s iPhone and iPad in 2015 and...
COJ #80 – The Red Flags in Mica Miller’s Death + Sandy Smith Meets with Investigators, Colucci Trial is Almost Here
For starters, Cup of Justice has a new Instagram account @COJPOD so be sure to follow for all the updates on exciting new guests, the Colucci case, and more. Investigative reporters Cup of Justice co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland — talk about what...
Listen Now: Happily Never After: Dan & Nancy
Nancy Brophy fills her novels with romantic betrayals and murder. It’s a far cry from her quiet life in the suburbs, where she and her chef husband, Dan, are living out their golden years. But when Dan is shot dead, Nancy finds herself at the center of a murder case...
COJ #79 – Handling Disputes with Neighbors, Harvey Weinstein’s Resemblance to Alex Murdaugh + Bye Bye, Noncompete Agreements
Cup of Justice co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland — talk about how to handle one of the worst kinds of disputes … having beef with your neighbors. How do you keep a fight with your neighbor from turning into an episode of “Fear Thy Neighbor”? Also on...
COJ #78 – Attorney Mandy Powers Norrell Shines The Light On Colucci Trial Strategies And Gives Voice To Victims
Cup of Justice co-hosts Mandy Matney and Luna Shark Producer David Moses are joined by attorney and prosecutor Mandy Powers Norrell to discuss the complexities of prosecuting the first Colucci trial and her own experiences prosecuting domestic violence cases. On this...
COJ #77 – Sandy Smith and the Zen of Airplane Travel, Bowen Turner’s Monstrous Behavior on Dash Cam + Lawyer-Legislator Sued Over Forged Settlement
Cup of Justice co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland — talk about the latest breakdowns in justice system, starting with Bowen Turner, the Orangeburg, South Carolina, man whose lawyer-legislator got him a sweet (and secret) plea deal in 2023 after three...
COJ #76 – Court TV’s Vinnie Politan On The Murdaugh and Colucci Cases And The True Crime Industry
On today's episode Co-hosts Eric Bland and Mandy Matney got to interview one of our favorite guests so far on this show… Vinnie Politian of Court TV. Politian is an Emmy winning journalists AND a former prosecutor who combines his journalistic talents with his legal...
COJ #75 – Alex Murdaugh Gets to Keep His Secret Money + Brandi Churchwell of the 13th Juror Podcast on the Karen Read Case
Right after we got back from Alex’s federal sentencing, Cup of Justice co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell broke down observations from the courtroom. Our intrepid journalists discuss the ins and outs of the 40-year federal sentence handed down to murderer Alex...
COJ #74 – Kate Middleton Backlash… Do Criminals Have Internal Monologues? + Feds Respond to Alex Murdaugh Co-Conspirator
Cup of Justice co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland talk about the backlash they received about their Kate Middleton episode and whether the princess’ announcement about her cancer diagnosis has changed their opinions. Also on the show: a discussion about...
COJ #73 – Redemption for Bowen Turner? Alex Murdaugh’s Big Bet, The Colucci Case and Kate Gate
Cup of Justice co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland — talk about what happens when lawyers want to back out of representing their criminal defense clients. The three also dive straight down the rabbit hole on the Kate Middleton mystery and look at why...
MMP #85 – Who Murdered Stephen Smith? Part Seven: Stephen Smith’s Death Now Officially A Homicide
Eight years after 19-year-old Stephen Smith’s body was found on a rural South Carolina road, investigators are finally saying the thing his family has known all along: He was not killed in a hit-and-run... STEPHEN WAS MURDERED.MMP co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell...
MMP #84 – The Latest on Stephen Smith, SLED’s Investigation into the Murders and Russell Laffitte’s Future
Thank you for your patience as this episode is publishing later than usual. As I said on social media, our team is in adjustment mode after the adrenaline and the chaos of the trial slowed down and we’re all still trying to all recenter our focus.Now that Alex...
MMP #83 – Alex Murdaugh Verdict: How We Got to Guilty + Creighton Waters Interview
Now that Alex Murdaugh has been convicted in the murders of his wife and son, it’s time to take a look back on all the pieces that had to come together for the jury to deliver that guilty verdict.Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell talk about key testimony in the case and...
MMP #82 – Week Six of the Alex Murdaugh Trial: ‘What A Tangled Web We Weave’
The trial of Alex Murdaugh is coming to an end and soon the jury will deliver its verdict.Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell break down the best and worst moments of the last week of testimony — including Alex’s big reveal that he was, as we all knew, down at the kennel...
MMP #81 – Week Five of Alex Murdaugh’s Trial: Maggie’s & Paul’s Last Day on Earth And The Timeline That Traps The Defense
The trial of Alex Murdaugh is now in its fifth week and the defense is trying its hardest to convince the jury that all of Alex’s big lies about what happened at Moselle that night don’t add up to life in prison.Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell unpack the state’s timeline...
MMP #80 – Alex Murdaugh Trial Week Four: How many lies will the jury buy?
We’re in the middle of week four of the Alex Murdaugh trial and it’s been – very on brand in the last week. Since the last podcast, the courtroom drama has been cranked up several notches.In this episode 80 of the Murdaugh Murders Podcast, Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell...
MMP #79 – Alex Murdaugh Trial Week 3: Trust, Brotherhood & Understanding The Motive
The third week of Alex Murdaugh’s murder trial started with a big blow to the defense after Judge Clifton Newman agreed to let the prosecution present evidence of the financial pressures Alex was facing at the time of the murders. Murdaugh Murders Podcast co-hosts...
MMP #78 – Evidence Stacks Up Against Alex Murdaugh In Week 2 Of Trial
We’re in week two of the trial against Alex Murdaugh and it’s been one heck of a high-speed rollercoaster ride as we learn more about the investigation into one of South Carolina’s most notorious crime sagas.Murdaugh Murders Podcast Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz...
MMP #77 – It’s Finally Here: The Trial of Alex Murdaugh Begins with Big Revelations
The trial of Alex Murdaugh has begun and already a lot has been revealed about the night he allegedly killed his wife, Maggie, and son Paul. Co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell discuss how jury selection went, why Alex’s family was suddenly there, the 255 witnesses...