AD-FREE EPISODES
TSP #20 – Why the Good Ole Boys Don’t Ever Give Up: A Bowen Turner Update + Alex Murdaugh’s Hysterical Reply to the Federal Government
Despite the past four years of basically becoming Murdaugh scholars, True Sunlight co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell still find themselves shocked when they see "good ole boyism" at work in South Carolina.On today’s episode, there’s a very frustrating update in...
TSP #19 – What Dick and Jim Want Jurors to Hear About Alex Murdaugh + Cory Fleming Seems to Be … Missing?
True Sunlight co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell have another mystery on their hands. Where in the world is Alex Murdaugh’s best friend and co-conspirator Cory Fleming? Also on today’s episode, the two investigative journalists go back down the rabbit hole to look...
TSP #18 – Actually, Alex Murdaugh WANTS to Be Difficult + Cory Fleming Isn’t Really Sorry At All
It’s been another wild week in the world of Alex Murdaugh. True Sunlight co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell give a breakdown of what happened at Alex’s federal plea hearing last week and the vicious dealings that have occurred since then. What is Alex’s larger...
TSP #17 – The Persecution of Becky Hill and What’s Really Going On With Alex Murdaugh’s Defense
Convicted murderer Alex Murdaugh is headed to federal court to plead guilty for the first time in any of his criminal cases. True Sunlight co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell take a look at the timing of this plea deal and how his motion for a new trial — with his...
TSP #16 – Cory Fleming Sentenced To 20 Years for Stealing Satterfield and Pinckney Money + Alex Murdaugh Has a New Trial Date
Last week, things spiraled into chaos again when Dick and Jim filed a long and shocking motion accusing clerk of Court Becky Hill of jury tampering.Liz and Mandy have spent days dissecting those documents as the accusations against Becky were very serious.We also...
TSP #15 – Sunshine On “A Mountain Mystery” – What Happened to April Jones? Part One
In this very special episode of True Sunlight, we continue our mission of getting the story straight and giving voice to victims. Eric Alan Daume reports from the Blue Ridge mountains of South Carolina and digs into the deaths of April Jones and Kevin Craig, and the...
TSP #14 – What Happened to Grant and Gracie Solomon? Part Three
What happened to Grant Solomon and what do we know about the police investigation…? If we look at that ONE event on its own … without the context of custody battles, molestation allegations, pressures over sporting achievements or connections to powerful...
TSP #13 – “I Don’t Think He Cared”: Cory Fleming Pleads Guilty To State Charges + Murdaugh’s Enablers Get A Taste of Big Creighton Energy
Every single time one of the boys “goes down” or we think they’re down, two more sprout from the surface showing their beady little eyes and empty souls. We've said this many times but our team is definitely experiencing Murdaugh fatigue. But we’ve noticed that the...
TSP #12 – ‘Coyote In A Trap’: Did Cory Fleming Pull a Fast One?
The first co-conspirator of Alex Murdaugh is finally behind bars! True Sunlight co-hosts Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell attended Cory Fleming’s sentencing hearing this week in Charleston, South Carolina, where they watched Fleming — a former attorney who took...
COJ #56 – Alex Murdaugh’s Plea Deal: Is This Justice?
Today’s show is fiery, y’all. Liz, Eric and Mandy are usually in agreement when it comes to Team Murdaugh and interpreting the winners and losers in their strategies. But not this time. The biggest question on our minds after Alex Murdaugh’s decision last week...
Bonus: Kathleen Madigan & Mandy Matney – A Sunny Side Bonus Episode
We're celebrating Book Launch Week with a Special Bonus Episode!!! In this special Sunny Side Bonus episode - Superstar comedian Kathleen Madigan joins Mandy to chat about true crime, psychopaths, Mandy's book, and everything else under the sun....
COJ #55 – Team Murdaugh’s Jury-Tampering Lie Has Been Exposed + Are Certain Lawyers Untouchable?
Happy Tuesday, y’all! We just got back from an amazing evening speaking with fans and students at the University of South Carolina. We're exhausted and our social battery is running low, but we are so thankful that the School of Information and Communication...
COJ #54 – The Worst Thing Team Murdaugh Has Done So Far + Judicial Hearing for Bowen Turner Prosecutor This Week
Happy Tuesday, y’all. First, thank you to everyone who joined the Talk Shop Live virtual event on Monday - Jenny Fisher and Mandy sold out signed copies, but don’t worry if you missed it, we are adding a few more for anyone that could not make the live broadcast. ...
COJ #53 – Who Has The Courage To Take on Alex Murdaugh’s Law Firm? + What Dick and Jim’s Latest Motion Might Tell Us About the Money
Happy Halloween, y’all! First, thank you to everyone who attended the two pre-book release events in Charleston this weekend. Mandy got the privilege to hug hundreds of listeners this weekend and that was the best feeling in the world. Mandy says, "I don’t...
COJ #52 – Unpacking Alex Murdaugh’s Chances of a New Murder Trial + Expectations For His Upcoming Financial Trials
Co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland — discuss the latest drama in the World of Alex Murdaugh. On today’s episode, the team corrects some of the headlines out there on whether Alex is getting a new trial. Plus how many losses have Dick Harpootlian and...
COJ #51 – The Big Gall on These Guys: In Murdaugh and Bowen Turner Cases, the Good Ole Boys Can’t Seem to Stop
True Sunlight Co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and everyone's favorite attorney Eric Bland — talk about the Federal Government’s latest reply to Alex Murdaugh’s galling attempts to seize his assets back from the state (and from the victims). Also on today’s show,...
COJ #50 – Silence and Leaks in the Stephen Smith Case + Why Cory Fleming’s Mysterious Absence Could Be Significant
Thank you all for supporting us and we're so excited to present this 50th episode of Cup of Justice!!! True Sunlight Co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and everyone's favorite attoryney Eric Bland — discuss Grand Jury leaks in the Stephan Smith case and what they...
COJ #49 – Russell Laffitte Is FINALLY Behind Bars + How Is Alex Murdaugh Paying Dick and Jim?
Alex Murdaugh’s co-conspirator Russell Laffitte — the small-town banker who said he asked no questions about Alex’s scheme and who allowed Alex to use and abuse his family’s bank — has finally turned himself in to serve his seven-year federal prison sentence. Co-hosts...
MMP #31 – Drug Smuggling And Operation Jackpot – What Happened To The Money? Part Two
What Happened To The Money? Part Two
MMP #30 – Who Was Maggie Murdaugh And What About Buster?
You asked, we answered. Our followers on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram submitted hundreds of questions about the case in the last week. A lot of you asked questions about the Murdaugh’s family history – who Maggie was... Who buster is... What was in Paul’s...
MMP #29 – How Many People Will Go Down For This?
After Friday’s indictments, Alex Murdaugh now stands accused of stealing at least $8.4 million and faces 74 charges. If the latest indictments told us anything, it’s that Alex did not do this alone - but how many people will go down for this? And how bad will this...
MMP #28 – What Happened To Hakeem Pinckney? Part One
Hakeem Pinckney was an inspiration. He spent his whole life overcoming the odds. His hearing started deteriorating at a young age, but he never complained. In fact, he won a national championship in football when he was a senior at the SC School for the Deaf and...
MMP #27 – ‘He’s in Trouble’: What Happened At Alex Murdaugh’s Bond Hearing This Week?
Current News In The Case
TRAILER: Murdaugh Murders Podcast
For nearly 100 years, one family traded influence and held power in the South Carolina lowcountry until a fatal boat crash involving an allegedly intoxicated heir-apparent shed sunlight on a true crime saga like no-other. Award-winning journalist Mandy Matney has...
MMP #26 – Who Killed Maggie & Paul? Part Two
Breaking News In The Case
MMP #25 – Taking On “The Firm” – Part One
Taking On P.M.P.E.D. A.K.A. “The Firm”
MMP #24 – Who Killed Stephen Smith? Part Five
After years of fighting for justice in her son Stephen Smith’s case, Sandy Smith has a renewed sense of hope that her son’s killer will be found. After she felt blindsided by her former attorney Andy Savage, Sandy Smith has hired Mike Hemlepp, Jr. as her new attorney....